Who should've been removed from the BABYMONSTER lineup

[jangshinz]

Honestly I feel like babymonster should've been a 4 member group. While I love the lineup, I feel like less is more, and the members that don't shine also don't really contribute as much (YG's fault). So, I would've done the lineup like this:

P01. Ahyeon Jung
Leader, Lead Vocalist, Lead Rapper, Lead Dancer, Center

Ahyeon is a solid pick. She has both consistent popularity in k-fans and i-fans, especially since she took a hiatus. Her skills are well developed.

P02. Ruka Kawai
Main Rapper, Main Dancer, Sub Vocalist

Ruka is the member from the Japanese line which I'd have chosen. She's a great rapper and dancer which Asa also is. However, Ruka is more popular and is the only trainee from BABYMONSTER/ Last Evaluation who did not specialise in vocals so the other three members could have vocal parts.

P03. Pharita Chaikong
Main Vocalist, Sub Rapper, Visual, Face of the Group

Pharita is one of the more unique singers in BABYMONSTER as she is able to use her own vocal tone to hit high notes. She has consistent popularity, less than Chiquita but in my opinion was more ready to debut.

P04. Rami (Haram) Shin
Main Vocalist, Lead Dancer, Maknae

Rami is another talented vocal in BAEMON and seems to be consistently utilised in songs. She was the member between her and Asa in which I chose Rami.

What will happen to...?
- YG was planning on saving asa for a Japanese gg for yg
- rora could've been saved for a 5th gen girl group
- Chiquita could've waited until she was older to debut

 

[BelenBlinkMonster]

Imo there are members who definitely shine more bcs they were chosen to stand out, ykwim, but honestly all of them have different assets to them. all though i completely disagree with your opinion on the positions and some of the statements made, i understand what you’re saying about the number of members bcs imo 5 is the most ppl a group should have.