- Joined
- Jan 6, 2024
- Messages
- 754
- Credits
- 14,202
disclaimer: no hate intended, this is my opinion not yours. I will mention both contestants eliminated in part1 and part2 contestants
vocals: 4.73
The vocals in the show have not been showcased enough. JIYOON and JUNGEUN are the clear standouts, as JIYOON is able to use emotion to enhance her already capable vocal talents while JUNGEUN can reach higher registers with a more connected head voice. UM JIWON had recently done a surgery on her mouth which prevented her from opening her mouth fully. However she still was a strong vocalist. FUKO, GYURI, MINSOL, SUJUNG, JEEMIN, YUI, SOUL and SARANG seem to have basic vocal skills, the former contestants being more stable while the latter being less. SUJUNG and YUI particularly improved during the 1:1 Position Test as they both use a breathy vocal technique yet took a bigger vocal part. KANG JIWON seems to have a developed lower register, but needs to improve her stability in higher octaves in order to advance. Everyone below is a weaker vocalist, thought SAEBI, KOKO and LINGLING have been improving/improved. Not the best vocalists but not the absolute worst.
Individual ranking -
1. Jiyoon - 6.5
2. Jungeun - 6.4
3. Um Jiwon - 5.8
4. Fuko - 5.6
5. Gyuri - 5.5
6. Minsol - 5.3
7. Sujung - 5.2
8. Jeemin - 5.1
9. Yui - 5.1
10. Soul - 5.1
11. Sarang - 5.0
12. Kang Jiwon - 4.8
13. Saebi - 4.5
14. Yuju - 4.4
15. Koko - 4.4
16. Lingling - 4.4
17. Juwon - 4.4
18. Yuiko - 4.3
19. Mai - 4.2
20. Eunchae - 4.1
21. Chaeeun - 3.7
22. Yeeun - 3.4
23. Yuna - 3.2
24. Nana - 3.0
rap: 5.39
There are few rappers among the contestants, it may be due to the fact that the PDS don't include raps in performances? YUI has a very good sense of tone and flow, it pays off to train with XG members. Both YUJU and KOKO are not far behind. They both performed very well on the main rapper stage, Spicy. YUJU has a good tone whereas KOKO has a better flow but both are equally good rappers. Notably, JIYOON, MAI and EUNCHAE had small rap parts during the entrance test. They all rapped decently but needed to show more material to be considered as better rappers. Possible rappers are JUNGEUN, SAEBI and SUJUNG who have been mentioned as rappers pre-show. I have not seen the proof so I will not include them as rappers.
Individual ranking -
1. Yui - 7.0
2. Yuju - 6.9
3. Koko - 6.8
4. Jiyoon - 5.2
5. Mai - 5.1
6. Eunchae - 4.7
7. The rest - 2
dance: 7.88
There is no standout dancer. Contestants like SUJUNG slowly blended in more as other contestants improved their dancing skills. The level of dancing is for the most part quite consistent. Everyone has developed basic dancing skills when at their best. SUJUNG, KOKO, JUWON, JEEMIN, MINSOL, YUI, YUJU, JUNGEUN and SARANG are the better dancers from a technical aspect, the former contestants being stronger and the latter being weaker. Kudos to SUJUNG who choreographed the whole Rain On Me dance for her team, as well as JUWON and JEEMIN for consistently being strong dancers. Contestants like NANA, UM JIWON, YUNA and SAEBI are in the midst of developing their skills. FUKO, CHAEEUN and MAI are actually better than what people expect, but they can't/didn't shine as much as others wanted them to. The rest of contestants are most likely below average, in particular KANG JIWON and YEEUN who don't put energy and effort into dancing. Overall a solid dance-focused lineup of contestants.
Individual ranking -
1. Sujung - 8.8
2. Koko - 8.8
3. Juwon - 8.7
4. Jeemin - 8.5
5. Minsol - 8.5
6. Yui - 8.5
7. Yuju - 8.4
8. Jungeun - 8.4
9. Sarang - 8.4
10. Nana - 8.4
11. Um Jiwon - 8.4
12. Yuna - 8.4
13. Saebi - 8.3
14. Fuko - 8.0
15. Chaeeun - 7.9
16. Mai - 7.9
17. Soul - 7.6
18. Gyuri - 7.6
19. Lingling - 7.6
20. Yuiko - 7.3
21. Eunchae - 7.0
22. Yoon Jiyoon - 6.3
23. Kang Jiwon - 5.8
24. Yeeun - 5.6
vocals: 4.73
The vocals in the show have not been showcased enough. JIYOON and JUNGEUN are the clear standouts, as JIYOON is able to use emotion to enhance her already capable vocal talents while JUNGEUN can reach higher registers with a more connected head voice. UM JIWON had recently done a surgery on her mouth which prevented her from opening her mouth fully. However she still was a strong vocalist. FUKO, GYURI, MINSOL, SUJUNG, JEEMIN, YUI, SOUL and SARANG seem to have basic vocal skills, the former contestants being more stable while the latter being less. SUJUNG and YUI particularly improved during the 1:1 Position Test as they both use a breathy vocal technique yet took a bigger vocal part. KANG JIWON seems to have a developed lower register, but needs to improve her stability in higher octaves in order to advance. Everyone below is a weaker vocalist, thought SAEBI, KOKO and LINGLING have been improving/improved. Not the best vocalists but not the absolute worst.
Individual ranking -
1. Jiyoon - 6.5
2. Jungeun - 6.4
3. Um Jiwon - 5.8
4. Fuko - 5.6
5. Gyuri - 5.5
6. Minsol - 5.3
7. Sujung - 5.2
8. Jeemin - 5.1
9. Yui - 5.1
10. Soul - 5.1
11. Sarang - 5.0
12. Kang Jiwon - 4.8
13. Saebi - 4.5
14. Yuju - 4.4
15. Koko - 4.4
16. Lingling - 4.4
17. Juwon - 4.4
18. Yuiko - 4.3
19. Mai - 4.2
20. Eunchae - 4.1
21. Chaeeun - 3.7
22. Yeeun - 3.4
23. Yuna - 3.2
24. Nana - 3.0
rap: 5.39
There are few rappers among the contestants, it may be due to the fact that the PDS don't include raps in performances? YUI has a very good sense of tone and flow, it pays off to train with XG members. Both YUJU and KOKO are not far behind. They both performed very well on the main rapper stage, Spicy. YUJU has a good tone whereas KOKO has a better flow but both are equally good rappers. Notably, JIYOON, MAI and EUNCHAE had small rap parts during the entrance test. They all rapped decently but needed to show more material to be considered as better rappers. Possible rappers are JUNGEUN, SAEBI and SUJUNG who have been mentioned as rappers pre-show. I have not seen the proof so I will not include them as rappers.
Individual ranking -
1. Yui - 7.0
2. Yuju - 6.9
3. Koko - 6.8
4. Jiyoon - 5.2
5. Mai - 5.1
6. Eunchae - 4.7
7. The rest - 2
dance: 7.88
There is no standout dancer. Contestants like SUJUNG slowly blended in more as other contestants improved their dancing skills. The level of dancing is for the most part quite consistent. Everyone has developed basic dancing skills when at their best. SUJUNG, KOKO, JUWON, JEEMIN, MINSOL, YUI, YUJU, JUNGEUN and SARANG are the better dancers from a technical aspect, the former contestants being stronger and the latter being weaker. Kudos to SUJUNG who choreographed the whole Rain On Me dance for her team, as well as JUWON and JEEMIN for consistently being strong dancers. Contestants like NANA, UM JIWON, YUNA and SAEBI are in the midst of developing their skills. FUKO, CHAEEUN and MAI are actually better than what people expect, but they can't/didn't shine as much as others wanted them to. The rest of contestants are most likely below average, in particular KANG JIWON and YEEUN who don't put energy and effort into dancing. Overall a solid dance-focused lineup of contestants.
Individual ranking -
1. Sujung - 8.8
2. Koko - 8.8
3. Juwon - 8.7
4. Jeemin - 8.5
5. Minsol - 8.5
6. Yui - 8.5
7. Yuju - 8.4
8. Jungeun - 8.4
9. Sarang - 8.4
10. Nana - 8.4
11. Um Jiwon - 8.4
12. Yuna - 8.4
13. Saebi - 8.3
14. Fuko - 8.0
15. Chaeeun - 7.9
16. Mai - 7.9
17. Soul - 7.6
18. Gyuri - 7.6
19. Lingling - 7.6
20. Yuiko - 7.3
21. Eunchae - 7.0
22. Yoon Jiyoon - 6.3
23. Kang Jiwon - 5.8
24. Yeeun - 5.6